Poll: Who's entry did you feel met the challenge and was worthy of your vote
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
[url=http://www.the-gauge.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=2974:d1v3jjrv][color=#FFD700:d1v3jjrv]Steamtrains-roundhouse[/color:d1v3jjrv][/url:d1v3jjrv] [color=#FF0000:d1v3jjrv]Completed project[/color:d1v3jjrv]
13.56%
24 13.56%
[url=http://www.the-gauge.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=3099:d1v3jjrv][color=#FFD700:d1v3jjrv]doctorwayne-Shanty[/color:d1v3jjrv][/url:d1v3jjrv] [color=#FF0000:d1v3jjrv]Completed project[/color:d1v3jjrv]
5.65%
10 5.65%
[url=http://www.the-gauge.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=3191:d1v3jjrv][color=#FFD700:d1v3jjrv]Gary S-bridge[/color:d1v3jjrv][/url:d1v3jjrv] [color=#FF0000:d1v3jjrv]Completed project[/color:d1v3jjrv]
16.95%
30 16.95%
[url=http://www.the-gauge.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=3288:d1v3jjrv][color=#FFD700:d1v3jjrv]TCWORLD-Turntable[/color:d1v3jjrv][/url:d1v3jjrv] [color=#FF0000:d1v3jjrv]Completed project[/color:d1v3jjrv]
8.47%
15 8.47%
[url=http://www.the-gauge.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=2956:d1v3jjrv][color=#FFD700:d1v3jjrv]scubadude-Wood cutter's shack[/color:d1v3jjrv][/url:d1v3jjrv] [color=#FF0000:d1v3jjrv]Completed project[/color:d1v3jjrv]
11.30%
20 11.30%
[url=http://www.the-gauge.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=3214:d1v3jjrv][color=#FFD700:d1v3jjrv]jim currie-Victorian house[/color:d1v3jjrv][/url:d1v3jjrv] [color=#FF0000:d1v3jjrv]Completed project[/color:d1v3jjrv]
7.34%
13 7.34%
[url=http://www.the-gauge.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=2954:d1v3jjrv][color=#FFD700:d1v3jjrv]nachoman-Enginehouse[/color:d1v3jjrv][/url:d1v3jjrv] [color=#FF0000:d1v3jjrv]Completed project[/color:d1v3jjrv]
7.34%
13 7.34%
[url=http://www.the-gauge.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=2932:d1v3jjrv][color=#FFD700:d1v3jjrv]Sumpter250-Boathouse[/color:d1v3jjrv][/url:d1v3jjrv] [color=#FF0000:d1v3jjrv]Completed project[/color:d1v3jjrv]
10.17%
18 10.17%
[url=http://www.the-gauge.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=2964:d1v3jjrv][color=#FFD700:d1v3jjrv]P5se Cameback-GERN plant[/color:d1v3jjrv][/url:d1v3jjrv] [color=#FF0000:d1v3jjrv]Substantial progress, project not completed[/color:d1v3jjrv]
7.91%
14 7.91%
[url=http://www.the-gauge.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=3229:d1v3jjrv][color=#FFD700:d1v3jjrv]RRManiac-Stilt Hopper Tippler[/color:d1v3jjrv][/url:d1v3jjrv] [color=#FF0000:d1v3jjrv]Fair progress, project not complete[/color:d1v3jjrv]
5.65%
10 5.65%
[url=http://www.the-gauge.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=2928:d1v3jjrv][color=#FFD700:d1v3jjrv]Puddlejumper-Firehouse[/color:d1v3jjrv][/url:d1v3jjrv] [color=#FF0000:d1v3jjrv]Fair progress, project not complete[/color:d1v3jjrv]
5.65%
10 5.65%
Total 177 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

2010 Summer Structure Challenge voting poll
#28
nachoman Wrote:Considering that on many of these projects, only a few of us ever get 100% completed... How about for the next project we vote based on the progress presented, not the finished work? That way, someone can note feel like they can't take on a huge endeavor. I mean, bil could have entered a small kitbashed office, but instead he chose to tackle the HUGE GERN facility. I bet he did more work on what he did accomplish than if he had completed a much smaller structure. Yes, there is a lot to be said about finishing a project, but I hate to see people underwhelm their abilities just so they can get something "done". So, for the next challenge, I propose:

"Find the oldest unfinished project on your workbench, and make substantial progress."
Kevin,

That's basically what we've been doing the past few challenges. If you note, not everyone on the list finished their project, but it's up to the voters to say whether or not it rates a vote or not. I agree, not everyone has the time they thought they had when committing to doing something, and they need to get credit for the excellent work they did put into it, and I think the best was to do that is just like we've done, list everyone that made an effort to get as far as they could dependent on the scope of the project and the time available.

And yeah, that's a good subject for a challenge, and one to get some of those old projects moved from the "to-do" list, to the "completed" list. I'm open to other suggestions for the next challenge, PM me with your ideas, or I can open another thread. We prefer to do things that our members like and suggest, so if we have a list of these suggestions, we'll go to that list first before trying to think of one ourselves. We don't always hit a home run with some of ours either. Nope
Don (ezdays) Day
Board administrator and
founder of the CANYON STATE RAILROAD
Reply


Messages In This Thread

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)