04-04-2012, 06:19 AM
I can see how it could add an interesting wrinkle to an ops session. On some layouts like a small switching layout, it could work. On a larger layout, it could be a hindrance. If you put a hinged box (or even duct tape a box) over the switch control, you can answer the question of "is it worth the effort?"
While Lance Minheim has done amazing work and revolutionized how we design and look at switching layouts, not everyone has to agree with all of his work. Remember, Lance is suggesting how to design and operate our layouts.
I love his Palmetto Spur layout, but I don't like the drill lead that's temporarily attached to the plan. I would just add a drill track with scenery that would either fold up, down, or swing sideways out of the way. Does that take away from the plan? Not at all. It just means I like it slightly different.
While Lance Minheim has done amazing work and revolutionized how we design and look at switching layouts, not everyone has to agree with all of his work. Remember, Lance is suggesting how to design and operate our layouts.
I love his Palmetto Spur layout, but I don't like the drill lead that's temporarily attached to the plan. I would just add a drill track with scenery that would either fold up, down, or swing sideways out of the way. Does that take away from the plan? Not at all. It just means I like it slightly different.
Mike Kieran
Port Able Lines
" If the world were perfect, it wouldn't be " - Yogi Berra.
Port Able Lines
" If the world were perfect, it wouldn't be " - Yogi Berra.